OK, obviously I'm doing something wrong here. I have a "Find Image on Screen" action with a pasted-in image, and it works fine.
I copied the image to the clipboard, pasted it into GIMP, and exported it as a .png file (I tried .jpg also).
Then I replaced the "Find Image on Screen" action with one that gets it from a file:
It doesn't work (it doesn't find the image on the screen). Anyone know what I'm doing wrong? Thanks.