I would suggest you use two macros.
The first, assumes you have the name selected. It will use the Copy action to copy the selection to the clipboard, and then execute a third sub-macro (using the Execute a Macro action) to work on the clipboard.
The second uses the Prompt for User Input action to ask for the name, and then sets the clipboard to that (using the Set Clipboard to Text action) and then executes the same sub-macro.
The third, sub-macro uses the Set Clipboard to Text action to add the date and time and a couple blank lines to the clipboard. After that it is just a matter of pasting it to the start of your !Prayer List Evernote note - I'll leave the Evernote users to answer that part (or search the forum for Evernote for possible answers).